The older I get, the more I realize how fallible I am.
— Roxane Gay
What failing do flat-earthers, antivaxxers and "big lie" believers share in common?
They all lack what psychologists call intellectual humility, the ability to admit you're fallible.
Duh.
While it's tempting to dismiss these kooks as childish, uniformed, or just stupid, psychologists would have us look deeper.
People who lack intellectual humility may also lack the abilities to evaluate evidence, enjoy learning, tolerate ambiguity, brook disagreement, appreciate expertise, or recognize the boundaries between reality and their egos.
People who lack intellectual humility, psychologists have discovered through seven decades of research, usually also have a screw or two loose.
In other words, they're cracked.
People with intellectual humility—the majority of us—realize they're fallible, according to the research.
They spend more time contemplating their beliefs, questioning their assumptions, and seeking out proof than those who lack intellectual humility.
People with intellectual humility in general are curious, inquisitive, tolerant, empathetic, forgiving, and cerebral.
People with intellectual humility in general are curious, inquisitive, tolerant, empathetic, forgiving, and cerebral.
People who lack intellectual humility, on the other hand, are self-absorbed, judgmental, dogmatic, over-confident, arrogant, combative, and carnal.
And what about the influence of world events on those who lack intellectual humility?
Sadly, psychologists have discovered that lack of intellectual humility worsens in the face of economic downturns, pandemics, wars, terrorist threats, and mass migrations.
They're also—as we well know—less able to distinguish truth from hoax.
Fortunately, although lack of intellectual humility is partly inherited, psychologists say there's hope for sufferers through cognitive behavioral therapy, which seeks to undo the bad influence of parents and teachers.
But can the rest of us wait for that?
Fasten your seatbelts, ladies and gentlemen.
More and more crackpots are heading your way!